22 Comments
User's avatar
James ( Jim) Marshall's avatar

The question of country size on the globe is simple to solve, we have satellite mapping from space to settle the matter, no debates! The question of global military bases is a matter of people in power, BOTH SIDES, over thinking their place in the global arena. We all know the matter of DEBT is the crazy people in Washington, BOTH SIDES, trying to keep their power by buying votes as they destroy our currency. We all know this train wreck is going to come to an ugly end.

Jim Marshall

Cat's avatar

Bill Bonner for President.

Mark H's avatar

"And no other country ever exported so much of its own dream — movies, books, ideas, language, fashion...you name it." And industry, and technology, and engineering know how, etc.

Cartero Atómico's avatar

Lots of ignorance on the right too. Remember when Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz said the invasion of Iraq would only cost $50 billion and be over in months? Speaking of the right didn't our dear leader say that his war with Iran was a little excursion and that the Warped Speed experimental mRNA vaccines were safe and effective?

Odin's avatar

There was an influential person in the past who stated that lies by government were OK if it helped to "direct" the people in the "right direction"

His surname was Burnays.

The master of psychological programming !

Cartero Atómico's avatar

Bernays did a great job convincing the US public to back Woodie Wilson's decision to enter WWI. Also in getting women to smoke. Evil comes in all forms.

Jimm Roberts's avatar

Bill eloquently stated what has always baffled me:

Why are we sustaining at enormous expense our post WW II role of restoring order which, at some point, mutated into making the world safe for Democracy?

Helping allies defend themselves against aggression, I understand.

But that mission ended in 1991 when the USSR collapsed.

Since then, our flag should be following trade.

If ever a conflict was deemed necessary, then it should only be assisting indigenous people replace cruel, oppressive dictators or assist them confront land thefts by invaders.

Cartero Atómico's avatar

Making the world safe for democracy was just a talking point the two teams made up to justify their actions. Just check out the number of CIA coups in which they overthrew democratically elected governments and installed dictators. FDR supposedly said of Somoza, our dictator in Nicaragua st the time, "He may be a son of a bitch, but he's our son of a bitch".

Robert Hall's avatar

Jimm: The mission that ended in 1991 resumed when we enriched a hostile China with our utopian trade policies.

D. Young's avatar

The UN is always acting like a naive adolescent. Now they are looking at each other and comparing size?

Map projections are what they are for a reason. Whose sense of geography are they trying to influence?

Anyway, this article was a waste of time. You spend too much time in Europe, Bill.

Tom Langdon's avatar

Well the human condition requires that we compare size and then rationalize that size makes no difference.

Robert Hall's avatar

The reason for the Mercator was to show sea compass headings as straight lines instead of curves. Maritime navigation back in the day was therefore simplified. Nothing sinister.

D. Young's avatar

There was an episode on West Wing where an advocate group was pressing the president to allow only maps that were printed "South Up" since the present maps implied inferiority to the southern hemisphere. The UN is exactly like that.

Homer Bell's avatar

Reasonable good post today, things we should be thinking about. Not much we can do about it, but both parties are responsible. We do need to change our ways for sure. All we can do is prepare as best we can for the situations to come. There are some really ignorant people in this country, they have no idea what’s going on,

Tom Langdon's avatar

To be ignorant is to be elite and not be aware of your ignorance, as the left gives ignorance a pass with encouragement.

Christopher Fogarty's avatar

Prosperity caused too many Americans to become swaggerers, braggarts, flag waving intervenors of other countries. Their numbers swelled during the era of official counterfeiting.

Angry Icebergs's avatar

Hegemonism, unilateralism and protectionism are resurging against historical trends.

Nevertheless, the overwhelming majority of the world do not condone power politics, conflict and confrontation, or isolation and backwardness.

-

It's hard to hear Xi say these things...

Over the screams of the enslaved Uigurs.

And the deafening war games aimed at Taiwan.

The Spratly's Great Wall of Sand and the threats to global shipping in the China sea.

The dumping of goods unto the worlds markets....

The encroachment of the silk road controlling foreign ports.

And global threats to withhold REE's unless "the use of" is approved by the CCP...

-

Really?

Did he mean it?

I mean Bill...

We know Xi didn't...

Xavier Narutowicz's avatar

I love America and hate the Empire. Maybe, what I loved is dead. There are now articles on Substack depicting the atrocities of empire, 55 million dead.

The American leadership is the great satan, as Christ said, “The Father of all lies.”

We have been swallowing the lies and rooted the home team. That makes us unworthy of the best part of the legacy that was past on by previous generations. We despoil our heritage.

And we are the most dangerous, the most liable to explode the world.

Depraved madmen lead us, those paid to look the other way and lie are scum.

It is hard to believe the level of prevailing idiocy.

I voted for Trump to destroy the deep state, and he has rewarded that vote beyond all expectations. The man is a genius. That is satire. Thanks for your service!

Kevin Beck's avatar

I can't completely blame the US for expanding their overseas empire. After all, they learned it from the worst: The Brits and the Latinos (oops ... Romans).

Odin's avatar

There was always a better option, but theft is quicker.

The end result is the same, and then comes the payback

As for the Chinese they have never forgiven what the British did to them, with the opium wars, and the theft of Hong Kong.

Fraser M's avatar

"No other country ever had an empire as large or powerful as America”?

Culturally, America is also recognisably British. Common law, representative government, suspicion of central authority, property rights, guns, flags, churches, county fairs and people insisting nobody will tell them what to do.

So I assume that by “American Empire” you mean the second, Western phase of the British Empire.

Britain built the global sea lanes, trading system, financial networks, naval infrastructure and spread of English. After 1945, America inherited that architecture and improved the model: fewer colonies, more bases, alliances, military guarantees, dollars and cultural influence.

Britain had to govern India. America got much of the same strategic benefit through sovereign allies, without the administration headache.

America didn’t invent an unprecedented empire. It inherited Britain’s dominant Western system, removed most territorial ownership and scaled it up.