35 Comments
User's avatar
Gordon's avatar

It's just too easy to spend other people's money, and Congress is addicted. Of course, the American people are also addicted to those dollars, whether SS checks, Medicare, people employed by the government, or contractors to the government. Cutting back will require pain, and thus far we would rather delude ourselves that everything will work out than deal with the pain of cutting back.

Of course, not cutting back will also bring pain, but we all hope it will be well in the future, and that it will be someone else who has to suffer. I do not know how this will turn out, but I have tried to prepare personally as well as I can.

Frank Westmoreland's avatar

Gordon, You really nailed it; and, very succinctly. Bill, unlike you and me, won't, for some unfathomable reason, blame this at all on the folks. You slash the debt, you slash jobs, which causes consumer spending to be radically reduced, which leads to more jobs lost (a cascading effect), which leads to a depression. And we all know the Democrats will never cut the debt, so it's up to the GOP to do it. And they are just smart enough to know that would be political suicide. The debt-for-jobs train left the station years ago, so it's too late to right the ship. So inflation/hyper-inflation will most certainly give it to the post-Baby-Boomer generations good and hard; maybe even sooner than expected.

Gordon's avatar

Sadly, I think that train left the GOP station decades ago. At least by the time Dick Cheney said, "Deficits don't matter. Reagan proved that." Neither side of the aisle - as a party - wants to deal with the deficit. Clearly there are individual congressmen who still care, but such a small number that they are impotent. Ron Paul did his best, but both sides viewed him largely as a crackpot.

Now we are approaching the crack-up boom as described by von Mises:

“There is no means of avoiding the final collapse of a boom brought about by credit expansion. The alternative is only whether the crisis should come sooner as a result of a voluntary abandonment of further credit expansion, or later as a final and total catastrophe of the currency system involved.”

—Ludwig von Mises, Human Action, p. 570 in the 1998 Mises Institute edition.

Anyone want to bet on the voluntary abandonment?

Jimm Roberts's avatar

Bill crafted an excellent layman's explanation how the Great Unraveling will occur.

What baffles me is why our elected and appointed officials whom we pay to guide our Ship of State are not taking steps now to steer clear of the shoals that will ravage our way of life.

If Argentina can smite inflation, why can't America?

Agent22Smith's avatar

Bill’s explanation for that makes sense. Change only occurs when pain becomes intolerable. We have not yet felt the pain of hyper inflation but the Argentinians had, hence the turn to Milei. But he is already encountering resistance from those who yearn for the good old days of the Peronists.

Frank Westmoreland's avatar

Mr. Roberts, Bill didn't say that Argentina smote inflation; he said they slowed it down. It is still quite high, and Argentina depends on the U.S. to protect it from the ChiComs, Russians, Jihadis, etc., saving them a tremendous amount of money. And they are a tiny country, population-wise, compared to the U.S., and very homogeneous. And Pres. Milei, who I greatly admire, still lost about 10% of his support in party elections. So there was a limit to how much inflation he could reduce without shooting up unemployment, and then be tossed aside, leading to the wild borrowing-and spending-Left taking over again and reversing what he has done.

Jimm Roberts's avatar

Excellent observations.

Worrisome too.

If a small homogeneous country like Argentina can’t restore fiscal sensibility, then how can larger ones?

Today, the next generation of French citizen, students, are demanding their government spend money for their betterment —money their government doesn’t have.

I foresee Stein’s Law will occur in France at some point. Then comes fireworks, the kind that hurt

Frank Westmoreland's avatar

Right, when the debt bubble starts leaking/bursting, it will have a world-wide effect, not just negatively affect the U.S.

Mackinac's avatar

Probably because they need a leader who attacks it directly.

James ( Jim) Marshall's avatar

Well I expect higher inflation or hyperinflation is a GIVEN! The story of governments never seems to change, only who is in power. MAX SAFETY MODE is the only plan that makes sense for me. Yes my cash will continue to loose its purchasing power but at the same time gold will rise in value so there will be a offset. (History will repeat). If you don't have a commodity that works opposite to the "fiat currency", you have a big problem. Plus NO DEBT! Being prepared is the only solution.

Jim Marshall

Don Hrehirchek's avatar

Yes, prepare as best as possible. As far as our knowledge will tell us. History is a guide, but has many a bumps in the road.

Mackinac's avatar

Agreed except gold may experience down periods which are hard to endure.

Brien's avatar

Gold has never done well in an environment of rising interest rates. We have seen that this year. If rates continue to rise look for gold to struggle. But watch what happens when the inevitable arrives. The government can’t afford a 5.25% rate for their entire portfolio. That’s a brick wall. But the rollover ladder and schedule are pushing them there fast. The only answer is lower rates. There is no other option. When that happens gold will take off again.

James ( Jim) Marshall's avatar

Very correct. Jan 29th was about $5540. Now gold is down about 25% YTD. The trend is still up. The last time I bought in June of 2011 it was about $1225/oz. Like a lot people I just watch it ride up and down and don't worry about it. It's the majority of my net worth (and non digital) and if I don't live another 20 years my daughter and grandkids will have a nice mental health cushion. Much like a farmer with a few thousand acres, he isn't taking it with him but he can smile and thank God for his good fortune. We all know paper is worthless so we better have something of historical value for a back up.

Jim

Bart Nelson's avatar

I would suggest the following solution. Immediate One Term Limits. No Pensions or benefits for elected officials. Balanced Budgets required every year. Reduce or eliminate all free money or benefit programs for anyone of working age who has the capability to work and contribute. If they don't train them too. Implement this and you will see the rats running out the Federal and State houses and agencies faster than when they came in. Most of the people that don't like or want to regulate AI are afraid because it exposes the truth about governments, agencies, universities, etc. The time has come to play hardball.

Tom Langdon's avatar

This is wishful thinking but to be sure it is a great thought.

JODCPA's avatar

Bart, you are on to something, but you missed one fine point. It is not the government's job to take care of anyone. Our society has been coaxed into thinking what sounds good is equal to what is right. Our government should build brudges and bombers and not be a bribery tool used by politicians.

On a moral note, what is moral about someone using the government to TAKE away what I have saved (by doing without, working harder than the other guy, spending less than I make...) and give it to someone else, whether they be elderly, handicapped, etc?

Thomas Sowell said it well when he said much of our social history for the past 35 years can best be described as doing what sounds good instead of doing what works. Like it or not, but families should be responsible for their families. I should not be repsonsible for yours, and you should not be responsible for mine. The irony of those who choose to not have children is that their "children" are not there to take care of them when they are old, so, they want my children ( or someone else's) to do it.

It's complicated, but it is not a government issue, in my opinion.

Cartero Atómico's avatar

AI exposes the truth that the technocrats behind AI want you to believe. Ask your AI who killed JFK and it will tell you Lee Harvey Oswald.

Conic Tonic's avatar

Go back to a serious gold standard … that would self correct everything you mentioned at once. Run out of gold … run out of spending!!

Phil Graham's avatar

The Feds and POTUS are looking at adding a wrinkle to the scenario - the GENIUS Act - where regular people are going to be bribed, nudged, hoodwinked and possibly even forced onto the stablecoin rail. The "Genius" being that USD stablecoins pay no interest at all - it all goes to the issuer via purchases of UST to back the USD stablecoin. In fact - it is beginning to look like the hope of the feds is that US debt will be increasingly funded by "retail" worldwide as consumers are pushed onto the rails in front of the oncoming inflation train.

Won't happen you say - as people see the loss of purchasing power by holding USD stablecoin instead of cash - but when you take away their ability to transact in cash and force most payments into the stablecoin network it's a done deal - it will start slowly at first - but soon consumers will be frozen out of online transactions unless they use stablecoin - next will be credit cards and eventually physical transactions. Ultimately the public will be holding instruments that pay 0 interest.

I'd love to hear Dan and Tom's take on what is likely coming and how they see it playing out.

David's avatar

This is a brilliant write up and a reminder that people only focus on the recent past or 'the last crisis'. I like the wisdom at BPR who take a longer term view. A monkey steering an elephant. Maximum safety mode indeed.

Kevin Wood's avatar

But it can’t happen here! That’s the prevailing belief because we’ve never seen hyperinflation before. The can will always be kicked down the road and all will be fine. Until of course, the road ends.

Egypt Solomon's avatar

Let me understand this, the US owes more money than exists in several dimensions, so the solution is to make the money worth less, that’s not economics, that’s changing the numbers on the bathroom scale because you ate the scale, but they have a beautiful word for it: inflation.

Inflation!

Wonderful word, sounds healthy, sounds like something a doctor does to your lungs.

Nobody says:

“Good evening Sir. Tomorrow your paycheck will quietly become 8% more useless.”

No, they say:

“We are allowing inflation to run moderately above target.”

That’s government language for:

The raccoon is inside the pantry, but statistically speaking, he remains near the door. And apparently the Administration discovered this trick after the Great Bixto War.

They borrowed mountains of money, waited several decades, inflated the currency, and eventually discovered that yesterday’s enormous debt could be repaid using tomorrow’s decorative currency.

Beautiful.

That’s like borrowing your neighbor’s lawn mower and returning a photograph of it forty years later.

“Technically, Gerald, the mower has retained nominal value.”

But there’s a problem, people eventually notice, because most people possess this annoying economic organ called a brain, you tell them prices will rise 10% every year, and suddenly everybody starts buying things today.

Landlords raise rents, workers demand raises, banks demand higher interest, bondholders demand compensation.

Grandmother takes one look at her retirement account and starts purchasing canned beans, copper pipe, and ammunition for reasons nobody at the Ministry of Finance wants to discuss.

Then President Trump yells:

‘WHY IS EVERYONE BEHAVING IRRATIONALLY?’

Irrationally?

You announced you were going to steal ten cents from every dollar we owned, what were you expecting dude?

A parade?

And then come the famous bond vigilantes. What a magnificent phrase, bond vigilantes, makes them sound like masked cowboys riding across the prairie defending fiscal responsibility.

They’re accountants clicking SELL!

That’s the posse, six men named Trevor sitting in climate-controlled offices saying:

“Four percent yield? Absolutely not.”

And suddenly the entire US Treasury is standing outside the capital wearing nothing but a necktie and asking whether anybody has fifteen trillion dollars by Thursday. That’s modern finance. Nobody knows where the money comes from. Nobody knows where it goes. But everyone agrees we need significantly more of it Immediately.

Think about it, the Administration runs a two-trillion-dollar deficit every year.

Excellent, apparently their fiscal philosophy is; we lose money on every transaction, but we make it up in volume. And politicians love inflation because inflation is the perfect tax.

Nobody votes for it, Nobody signs it, and nobody receives a bill. Your groceries simply cost thirty percent more and some minister appears on television explaining that the economy remains “surprisingly resilient.”

And Corporations suddenly discovered greed?

Apparently for the previous two hundred years corporations were charitable monasteries. Then Tuesday came:

“Gentlemen, I have terrible news.”

“What?”

“We can charge MORE MONEY.”

“Dear God!”

Meanwhile government spending climbs faster than a Bixto tourist leaving downtown LA after accidentally asking what the national debt is.

And the Administration adopts the genius solution:

What if we intentionally create 10% inflation?

Brilliant, but why stop there?

Make it 20%, Hell, make it 80%, you’ll pay off the entire national debt by Friday and a loaf of bread will cost 11 million dollars by Sunday, but congratulations, the Treasury Department is debt-free.

Citizens will be eating drywall seasoning packets for dinner, but the spreadsheet will look fantastic. And that’s the magical moment when inflation becomes hyperinflation. Nobody knows precisely when. It’s economics’ version of alcoholism. Nobody remembers the exact beer where everything went wrong. You’re just standing naked in a fountain six years later arguing with a parking meter.

Argentina knows this movie, other countries know this movie, But the US doesn’t, the US watches other countries experience monetary collapse and thinks, “that could never happen here.”

Why?

Because we’re the US of A!

Excellent argument, that’s also what every drunk driver says immediately before introducing his automobile to municipal landscaping.

In all honesty, I think the plan sounds pretty good. I mean, the country owes an impossible amount of money. So they’re going to destroy the value of money.

Seems reasonable.

I had an uncle who owed the bank 100K.

Burned down the bank and never received another statement.

He went to prison, but the correspondence problem was solved.

Let’s examine a US Treasury bond.

The government intends to inflate away their investmenT, and they demand higher interest rates, which increases government interest expenses.

Which increases deficits.

Which requires more borrowing.

Which creates more inflation.

Which causes investors to demand higher rates.

That seems unfortunate!

Has anyone considered borrowing more money?

Of course, The Administration, that’s a brilliant plan, wouldn’t want them to overthink it.

The Washington Post headline soon reads:

US ECONOMY REMAINS STRONG DESPITE TOTONIANS BEING UNABLE TO AFFORD THINGS

Very Comforting.

Turn the page.

GOVERNMENT ANNOUNCES NEW PROGRAM TO HELP CITIZENS AFFORD PRICES CAUSED BY PREVIOUS GOVERNMENT PROGRAM

Even better!

Another page.

PROGRAM TO BE FINANCED THROUGH BORROWING

Now we’re cooking!

Bessent asked whether hyperinflation was inevitable.

No Scott, nothing is inevitable, but the government could reduce spending.

JODCPA's avatar

the essence of this......is that democracy does not work. one father of the country nailed it with saying democracy only works when you have an educated, moral electorate. I just can't see how the vote of a non-productive person who cannot manage their own affairs would be beneficial to running a responsible government. A taker is only going to take.

Lucas Kandia's avatar

"Here’s what will happen. The feds will allow inflation to ‘run hot.’ Interest rates will go up."

That line. I keep hearing it from Bill over and over. Trump doesn't want high interest rates. But it ain't the interest rate at the bank that will be going up. It finally dawned on me, after years of listening to Bill. And hearing him converse about T-bills in the same article.

It will be the interest rate on those T-bills. That will go up. Something Trump cannot control. Otherwise, why the hell would anyone buy one?

Unless Donald has a plan for that as well.

Larry Cass's avatar

This is why I continue to accumulate PHYS.

altschule's avatar

Oh yes of course there is another brilliant 'answer' to all US problems .. RE-ELECT DJT he'll save us all .. the god of netanyahoo puta rjt sent them to save mankind .. just suck on them like delicious lollies and you'll be saved .. and don;'t forget to wear your red caps or yarmulke's !!!

Salters Trader's avatar

If rampant inflation is such a certainty, why is BPR not recommending TIPs or some other product that responds well to inflation and is not tied to the USD? I understand precious metals and I understand USDs and very short term treasuries for short term liquidity, but what about a product that gains when inflation goes up?

Richard dal's avatar

For TIPs to work, you'd have to believe the governments CPI numbers. Hold gold in inflation, not paper.

Salters Trader's avatar

I own gold and have been investing in it for 50 years. But what you don't mention is the lack of any income or guarantee of appreciation for potentially many years in a row. Of course our government and the monetary system might collapse but in the meantime, it would be nice to have some income and also something to hedge inflation. And it never hurts to have some diversity.

Ian's avatar

We seem to have a number of competing narratives at BPR for the ‘end times’ now. Thought we were the handicappers, not the ones making bets!

Dennis T.'s avatar

it's the surprise I have prepared for since 1995.

Richard dal's avatar

4th Turnings are probably inevitable but looks like those running the show plan on dealing with it with Agenda 2030, programmable stable coins and CBDC's, UBI, wealth disparity / feudalism 2.0. Thought POTUS might stop the worst of it. But no.

Worm Farmer extraordinaire's avatar

Yes. I have long said I want my depression under Trump. I voted for the idiot three times. Sadly, give the choices to vote for again. I simply can’t stand him