As it relates to the ruling class manipulating its subjects I fully agree. As it relates to the English invading Ireland and the past 850 years of that history, it is what it is. There are a few more years of history in the Middle East and no matter what you say or think, just as man can not change climate, you will not change what happens in the Middle East. So let us get back to attempting to save the USA. A country led by elites, who feel as if they are the chosen to fix all but their own and fail at everything they touch. Let us stop letting them hide behind wars in other lands and focus on the war we have here at home.
When Bill devolved into his recent antisemitic rants of late, I wondered to myself if it was possible that one of the sources of his hatred came from his Irish heritage and a resultant confusion of the struggles between the English and Irish with the present Israelis and Palestinians. I didn’t opine at that point because I didn’t know enough about Bill besides his Irish last name. I wonder no more. Bill is seriously confusing the two.
The list of differences between the Irish and the Palestinians is VAST. Most importantly, the Irish were not backed up and funded by 1.8 billion English haters to advance their invariant charter to wipe all of England and the English people from the face of the earth.
Bill, you are far more antisemitic than you believe. You are also confused and confusing based on your personal issues, history and problems. I expected better from you.
Sadly, today qualifies for another donation to the IDF. If you’d like to help, please go to FIDF.org
Dr B -- Your accusation that Bonner hates Jews is getting tiresome.
His assessments of events are not indicative of religious hate. They are poignant observations of man's capacity for virulence.
Consider our history. Atrocities abound. Some were attributable to religious hatred; others were racial hatred; the rest were hate unleashed.
More: I have never understood why people hate Jews or Blacks or Catholics or the Irish for that matter. Totally baffling were German soldiers who worshiped Jesus -- a Jew -- murdering Jews during WW II.
All I can conclude, notwithstanding our many religions all which teach tolerance and peace, we are a species of born killers
Not that baffling. His fellow jews murdered Him. The present day jews still don't recognize their Messiah. So their hatred of jews is logical, but that doesn't make it right. There were also other reasons for the German hatred of the jews, but that's another story, which you can find on the interwebs, but you'll have to dig deep.
You make my point about our species being imbued with a capacity to hate without restraint and to murder without limit.
Previously dominating the news were daily details about two Slavic tribes -- Russians and Ukrainians -- slaughtering each other
Now, we have Jews and Arabs slaughtering each other.
Not sure what fatal feud will be next but there will be one that will be especially vicious, maybe more than one. It's our nature to kill each other for the littlest of provocations.
Selfish people are self destructive, Jimm, both to others and themselves. And, what we do to others we are really doing to ourselves. Haven't you read Discourse On Agape? None of this should surprise us.
Jesus wasn't murdered by Jews. The Vatican said so in the Second Vatican Council in the 1960's and subsequent Popes have said so as well. Furthermore a number of distinguished historians of Jesus have said so as well. It's called libel.
And, Paul didn’t have a letter from the high priest giving permission to kill followers of Jesus. And Paul himself, in his travels, was denounced and beaten by Jews. And probably, many Christians were denounced by Jews to Roman authorities.
When Germany was prostrate, from inflation and financial collapse, because Jews kept hard money, provident behavior we participate in, they improvidently bought people’s lives on the cheap.
I apologize, I didn't know that. I know that a church that murdered millions and millions of Christians, and has a large number of pedophile priests (and covered it up for who-knows-how-long), will certainly tell the truth about who murdered Jesus.
(((they))) have the rep for murdering most of the Torah faithful prophets too !! ... Hypocrit oath takers, are very familiar with practicing the genocide concept also.
Sure, we are all born killers capable of hatred. That truism aside, it’s face valid to me (and I believe many others) that Bill has directed and displaced a big slice of his own hatred’s into antisemitism which he feels compelled to present in his newsletter. I find that particularly gross, unseemly and unwelcome. If you can’t see it, little would be advanced by my listing all the examples and demonstrating their historic and present role as propaganda points for anti-semites throughout recorded history. Anti-semitism is a bit like pornography - you know it when you see it. When you share it, you will never see it.
I fully endorse the Israelis killing (or murdering, whichever you prefer) all of Hamas by the most expedient, violent methods available to them. The loss of life of so called "innocents" in the process is somewhat regrettable but since the Palestinian Charter says the purpose of so called "Palestine" is the eradication of the Jews and the Palestinians have had 70 odd years to make peace with the Israelis and yet they haven't done it I'm not overly concerned with the loss of life in Gaza. Every Hamas fighter that gets killed is wonderful news and any so called "innocents" who lose their life is just tough darts.
Sometimes picking sides and rooting for the home team is the right thing to do. Next up, Israel v Hezbollah so Bill, please don't use that one to make another analogy to make a larger point.
If you think your opinion matters to me you are sadly mistaken but I will say your reply speaks volumes about who and what you are and that is even less compelling.
Jim. If you say anything about Israel, other than extremely high praise, you are antisemitic. The same as if if I did not vote for Obama, I am a racist.
WFE: You start out great with your comment...then you do a 180 and make a very stupid remark.."if I did not vote for Obama, I am a racist"...dumb, dumb and dumber. It makes no sense. Maybe you should reevaluate your medication.
I have no idea why people hate blacks, but I know why Christians and Muslims hate Jews. Both religions have a problem besides both being utterly false. The problem is Towrah, Prophets, and the Psalms. These books teach an opposite message than both religions, and let it be noted to Rabbinical Judaism as well. The Jews with their Towrah knowledge were seen as a threat to the ruling religious elite of Rome and Europe.
Muslims hating Jews is somewhat the same idea, Surah 5:44 Indeed, We sent down the Torah, in which was guidance and light. The prophets who submitted [to Allāh] judged by it for the Jews, as did the rabbis and scholars by that with which they were entrusted of the Scripture of Allāh, and they were witnesses thereto. So do not fear the people but fear Me, and do not exchange My verses for a small price [i.e., worldly gain]. And whoever does not judge by what Allāh has revealed - then it is those who are the disbelievers.
Distilled into English: Muhammad purchased Talmud verses from the rabbis to flesh out his Quran. Nothing works better for a religion than associating with the God of Abraham. The problem exists in these Rabbis knew Muhammad twisted the verses they sold him, and there's no better way to cancel a debt than murdering the creditors.
The Roman Church as a similar problem, as did the author of Christianity Paul of Tarsus. Yahowah was very clear there is one Towrah for both the Native born and the foreigner. No need for a new covenant or new way into the family of God.
Exodus 12:49 This instruction applies to everyone, whether a native-born Israelite or a foreigner living among you.” The Jews were very familiar with this verse, a good reason to drive them underground.
Dennis T -- Your edification is as elucidating as it is provocative. The latter sensation because it makes clear that all religions are made-made.
Fortunately, all the many religions -- now and in the past -- have at their core the same sentiment; that is, "Do Unto Others What You Would Have Them Do unto You."
Hopefully, the ones certain to be created in the future by persuasive men and women will perpetuate this sensible and perpetually apt belief
(For some reason, after I finished the last sentence above, I had a flash back. It took me to the moment many years ago when I visited a museum in Instanbul. It was somewhere near the Hagia Sofia, aka the Blue Mosque which was once Christendom's second largest cathedral
The particular museum case that caught my attention explained its contents were plundered by the Ottoman Turks in the 14th century from a museum in Damascus. And there, at eye level height, was Mohammad's sword, the very instrument he used to savagely proselytize his new religion).
The ancient world was a series of thefts, Persian was robbed by the Greeks, the Greeks by Rome. The Byzantines by the Ottoman Muslim Turks, the Ottoman's by Europe, Europe by America. With lots of mayhem and murder along the way, but all in the name of one god or another.
What is lost on the adherents of all religions is the why of religion. Simply put there's no better means to install and support a cast system. The top is always the king, or landowner, followed by the generals, and religious clerics, with the bottom rung of slaves.
The Pope had an army and clerics under him, followed by serfs.
Muslims have their elites the very rich, next the Imams, and mujahideen, all others are slaves.
The God of Abraham instituted no religion, the Covenant is a family. Choosing religion, politics, or the military, puts one outside of the family.
As noted on the first tablet given to Moesh those who show love by listening and living by relying on God are counted in the thousands or one in a million mathematically. Those who show hate corrupt their children via religion even to the third and forth generation, after that time the children's corruption is self sustaining as can be witnessed in all religions. We do what our parents have done for generations, human nature is in taking the easy road, the popular path. This explains how the Arabs were not at all bothered with torturing the children of the Jews while the parents watched and then slit their throats, or burned them alive. It was all done for Allah who is greater, larger, better than every other god.
Me thinks you’re onto something. Irish hatred for the British runs pretty deep. And Not without good reason.
It was the British, once they took over the portions of the Levant, that controlled Mandate Palestine from the early 1920’s till 1948. It was the British who followed through on the Balfour Declaration circa 1915, a prescient document in light of the atrocities of the Third Reich. Perhaps it was a fit of conscience after their attempted genocide of the Irish that moved them to help found the state of Israel.
The British PM at the time, played fast and loose with the break up of the Ottoman empire. The Arabs were promised the same lands as the French, the Balfour declaration was created to induce the zionists to induce American into WW1 causing the defeat of Germany and Russia. However the the Bolsheviks taking over Russian threw a monkey wrench into the works by publishing the secret dealings of England, the Arabs were not too happy with the same property being promised the French. Moreover the Jews were not to happy finding out the British had promised the Arabs that a declaration had no weight in comparison to a treaty.. The British went on to screw the Zionists out of their homeland. Not to worry the next time the British need the help of the Jews to induce America into WW2 they got their, homeland. Furthermore, the Jewish inventor of artificial silk (Rayon) disclosed the process to the British as a trade for the Jewish homeland. Technically, all the modern problems in the Middle East were caused by the British screwing the Arabs out of what they were promised, Israel was just the straw the broke the camels back. It's not at all about the land, Israel is a nothing compared to the millions of square miles controlled by the Arabs. What the zionists bought from the Arabs was worthless desert. Kind of like buying an old broken down homestead on the southern cost of Ireland. It has no real worth or value until a lot of effort and money is applied, then someone might have some interest.
I can only add that it’s my understanding that Gaza was considered part of Egypt until 1967. I expect their control started after the end of hostilities in 1948 which as noted above began b/c the Palestinians and more importantly their Arab neighbors could not countenance the idea of a Jewish state in their neighborhood.
It's very difficult to apply the word illegal to international events, even when "international law" is involved it is a very difficult and complex subject.
I have a feeling you are more informed on the technicalities of the UN regarding Israeli statehood. Tip O'Neal once said that politics ain't beanbag. International politics is worse.
My ancestors were potato-famine Irish from County Antrim. I can't tell an Irish Catholic from a Protestant.
In fact I once met a mother and daughter in clinic who were behaving like the television caricature of a Jewish mother and daughter. When I enquired about their origin I was told "Palestinian." Oops, but I hadn't let on my initial impression.
I can tell Somalis from Ethiopians- geographic neighbours but quite distinctive. I am not sure I could pick out an Eritrean.
You report on the situation in the nearby Arab states. I have long wondered who benefits from maintaining the Palestinian segregation.
The price of the (olive) oil that my wife likes (organic, first cold-pressed) is up from C$9.99/l to C$18.99/l from 2021 to now, so there is some hope for at least increased profitability.
Hmmmm - great info to have. Now the million $$ question:
Why does NO COUNTRY want these people? Are all the Arab "brothers" wrong, or do they 𝙠𝙣𝙤𝙬 a Reality about the people of "palestine" that our media, government, Bill Bonner and leftists refuse to acknowledge??
Gen. 10:4 “What Have You Done? -Said the Lord. Listen! The Blood of Your Brother Calls Out From the Ground;” in Irish, is what my wife and I have carved into all of the Holocaust mass grave monuments we have installed in Ireland. We installed them over Holocaust mass graves at the requests of locals too afraid of their government to do so themselves. The “Irish” government is extremely hostile to any recognition of those mass graves, especially to any references to the sixty-seven named British regiments who stripped the food crops from their Irish producers and exported it; starving millions to death.
I took a subscription for financial commentary and a non prejudiced world view from Mr. Bonnor and associates. I enjoy his economic theories and opinions of what is wrong with the USA and possible solutions. I agree with you on the Midfle East. Either he doesn’t like Jews or has no idea what he is talking about. I will not renew my subscription.
I don't think the Irish hate Jews, I believe a few years back the mayor of Dublin was a Jew.
One thing about the Irish no matter who you are if from America they love you.
Other than the Jews no one has suffered more than the Irish. England came very close to eradicating the Irish.
A few years back I learned my grandfather one my father's side was kin to Sean Treacy one of the leaders of the Third Tipperary Brigade of the IRA during the Irish War of Independence. My grandfather was brought over to America by Edward Stotesbury to act as his carriage driver and later his chauffeur at his estate in Wyndmoor, PA.
Dr B, imo Bill is not antisemitic. He aspires to not be “anti” anything. He is a philosophical libertarian and as such dreams of a world in which moral judgments have been outlawed. It takes mental effort to discern between right and wrong, good and evil. Best to just close one’s eyes, cover one’s ears and anesthetize one’s mind so that no effort need be made. Notice, however, that it is impossible to not take sides between good and evil. When one refuses to identify the moral difference between initiatory force and self-defense one raises murder to the level of virtue.
There are a lot of anti-Semitic libertarians. Lew Rockwell and Ron Paul come immediately come to mind. Anti-Semitism exists in all ideologies. That it is as prevalent on the “left” as it apparently is comes as a surprise to many of the left.
If you think that you don’t know what Objectivism or libertarianism is. The Ayn Rand Institute is unequivocally on the side of Israel in this conflict.
Heck, guess not. Whatever happened to Objectivists not getting involved in politics by not voting! Shows you how long I’ve paid attention! Lol! Guess every thing has its cycle. Next you’ll be telling me the Libertarian’s support global involvement!
The Palestinians have been offered peace. There is no correlation to the Irish situation. It was not an army that attacked the Israeli civilians it was a terrorist organization that has vowed to kill all Israelis. Does that include the two million moslems in Israel?
Years ago the Prime Minister of Israel even offered the city of Jerusalem to the Palestinians. A huge mistake. The Palestinians refused. Palestinians do not want peace. They fully believe, as does Iran, that Israel should not exist. Period. They chant, "death to Israel, death to America!". To them we are big satan and Israel is little satan. For this administration to give any money to Gaza/Hamas is a mistake. But the truth is, they have already given multiple billions, starting with B.O., to J.B., through Iran. They are funding our own destruction.
From the beginning of time until today there have been wars. Wishing they wouldn't happen is folly. There is a spirit of darkness, and a spirit of light and never shall the two agree. My heart is fading in its attachment to life on earth. This place is just the decision field of where we go afterward. My purpose now is to pray and hope that my children, along with as many people as possible, make the right choice.
The main terrorists in Palestine were the Stern Gang and Irgun. They were not Palestinian; but were Khazarian. In 1948 they attacked and murdered much of the populations of some 480 Palestinian towns and villages. The survivors and their progeny remain in refugee camps awaiting restoration to their homes and property. The same terrorists blew up the King David Hotel which housed Britain's local military HQ, murdering all within.
Many durable lies, the best lies, have a grain of truth in them. Read “1948” by Benny Morris, the history of the formation of Israel. You can see all of it. The good, the bad, and the ugly. Parse the information and make up your own mind.
Do you not wonder about the fanatical devotion of some people to assembling intricate arguments invoking all kinds of nonsense to rationalize hatred of a people they don’t even know? What kind of emotional health does that person have? You might also consider how many Jewish terrorists you are aware of in your lifetime versus Islamist terrorists. How many times have Jews shot up a school
Or a shopping mall or a restaurant, hijacked a plane, or taken hostages, or had suicide bombings performed by 16 year olds? Look around the world and let me know. The Islamist Muslims blow everybody up - Muslims, Jews, Christians, Hindus, Animists, Atheists, usually civilians. The Palestinians pay the families of murderers and stipend. Pretty nifty. And Uncle Sam subsidizes that stuff. You can figure it out.
It’s not hard to understand right from wrong even while the bombs are dropping.
Nice try, Bill. Since you can't make the same case for the Palestinians, you have to substitute the Irish. But you are so biased, you won't delve into the facts of the situation, or you just skip over the facts and history that don't support your narrative. As I've said before, why you go on and on about this in what is supposed to be a financial newsletter is very puzzling. But, by contrast, it does allow me to appreciate the columns by Dan, Joel, and Tom that much more since they are more informative, interesting, and enjoyable in terms of the reason I signed up for this service.
God did give the land, and the whole earth, to Abraham, and his descendants. His descendants are all that have the faith of Abraham. That doesn't include the vast majority of the current inhabitants in the state of Israel. Haven't you read my little booklet, The Two Covenants? I summarize what God gave Abraham in the booklet; check it out at https://discourseonagape.org/booklets/
According to DNA studies relatively conducted by Hebrew Univ. and Johns Hopkins Univ. the current genocidists of Palestine, the Ashkenazi Jews some 98% of whom have zero percent Abrahamic ancestry, denounce anti-Semitism, while Palestinians, robbed of their ancestral lands and homes, are of some 98% Abrahamic origins.
Starboard - this is the party line from the Soviet Union. The whole genetic disassociation myth was started by the Soviets, in addition to all the ""Khazarian"dreck, which is like Snow White and the 7 Nazis, a fairy tale. Multiple studies, easily searched online from serious scientists show that Ashkenazi Jews have over 50% DNA from the Levant. In other words, more than a lot of Palestinian Arabs.
Furthermore, in my case, my brother had the genetic thing done a few years back. Before I turned gray, I was a blonde haired, green eyed kid with a slavic name. Plug my DNA into the sorter and it turns out that my family was in the Iberian Penninsula ( Sephardim) and before that in Southwest Asia, aka Israel.
Start there. SO when somebody boldly lies to your face, take with a grain of salt every other thing that comes out of their mouth or off their keyboard.
Many religions have been barbaric. The inquisition did not end until 1850. Unfortunately parts of the moslem religion are still barbaric. Remember, Bonner, one of their goals is to murder you.
I have never heard those words used like that and I never read them in the Talmud either. Besides, what is your point. Judaism has evolved into a religion that is not barbaric unlike islam
False also - of course. Given that your obvious goal is to state incendiary falsehoods, I won’t put energy into tracking down each of your lies for historical correction. I’ll just write you off as full of crap.
Two years ago the msm informed the public of the dedication of Israel's leaders to their religion. Seeing that there is so much vengeance, paedophilia, and encouragement of genocide in the Old Testament, and that Christ had introduced the anti-toxiins of forgiveness and redemption. that official Israel's decades-long genocide of Palestine is probably due to the perpetrators' religion. The horrors inflicted on Gaza cannot be condoned other than, say, in Deuteronomy. Would be happy to learn that what my eyes observe of Gaza districts rendered flatter than WW2 battle scenes, is all anti-Jewish propaganda. If only. Man's Inhumanity to Man Makes Countless Thousands Mourn. We all mourn including for those murdered on Oct 7.
Deuteronomy does not condone what is being done in Gaza, and further, does not condone violence. The Bible states facts, often ugly facts, but God does not condone them.
I leave it to someone else to educate you about the Quran, but your statement about the Talmud is absolutely false. There is no word “shiksas” in the Talmud. There is a Hebrew word “sheketz” in the Talmud which refers to the daughter of an uneducated and unobservant Jew. Has nothing to do with gentile women or with prostitutes.
I personally know lots of Jews who abhor the Israeli Government. So using Statist illogic; they're all Anti-Semites. Completely juvenile and risible :-)
DNA tests relatively recently conducted by Hebrew University and Johns Hopkins Univ. on European Jews and Palestinians, show that some 98% of European Jews have zero Semitic ancestry, while Palestinians ARE of 98% Semitic ancestry.
"and even now are protesting the massacre in Gaza."
Are you speaking about the "palestinians"? I'd truly LOVE to see that, it would go completely against my "conditioning", but I strive to be accurate in what I think and believe. Always ready to assimilate new FACTS or EVIDENCE.
There’s nothing wrong with criticizing Israel the state. But when you single it out for special criticism and employ a double standard which ignores the bad behavior of every other state including the Muslim world like a lot of people do, then it’s not just Israel you are criticizing. It’s Jews. Everybody has their opinion. As far as Jews who criticize Israel, that’s fine too. But if you are a Jew who thinks that this type of criticism will score you points with the cool kids, and that they will overlook your religion and you get a pass , think again. Haters gonna hate.
who is this 'we' , that you speak of ?? If it wasn't for the US of A, Inc. being a bought and paid for zionist lapdog, you'd get your asses kicked into the next century. 'Star of Remphan' is all one needs to know.
Very true. Jews in Israel vary widely in their views of their own government in any given issue.
I’d also opine, that the conflict between an ocean of Muslims and a tiny island of Jews has less to nothing to do with governments, territories, etc., and everything to do with religious intolerance. Simply put, there are no modern Islamic countries where any other religion is tolerated. There is zero tolerance. Full stop. If all Israeli Jews converted to Islam tomorrow, the murderous attacks would cease. If jews surrendered 80 percent of modern day Israel to a Muslim country do you think the charter to kill the remaining jews would change?
Typical nonsense from Dr B. There is a large jewish community in Iran. They are allowed to worship as they please, and even have a voice in their Parliament. Many of them are descendants of the jews rescued from France in WWII by Iran.
The 'B', in Dr. B ... stands for 'mierda de toro' ... the usual name changing ... a long established Khazarian practice of stealing the identity of the victim for the promotion of futher chaos, and corruption. See: 'Noahide Laws'.
You are sadly mistaken. The Jewish population in Iran (as well as every single Muslim country) has been plummeting for decades. The few Jews left in Iran mostly fled (if they could get out) during the Islamic revolution. Jews who lived in Iran were segregated and and discriminated against in every facet of life.
Yes, but the Statists among us like to conflate the two. For example, Bill Bonner didn't say anything derogatory about Jewish people or their religion. Bill didn't praise the Hamas butchers. On the contrary, he called them out for the barbarians they are. However, Bill did criticize the Israeli Governments response; the mass punishment of all Palestinians living in Gaza. For that viewpoint, Bill was labeled an Anti-Semite by the Statists residing on our forum. Nine out of ten people you run into are Statists, but they'll never admit it. However, when you know what to look for they're very easy to find. America will never regain its past glory as long Statolatry remains our national religion.
The christian religion has killed millions so your logic is totally misplaced. Furthermore there is no genocide in Gaza. Israel has always tried to avoid civilian deaths. That is not genocide. Was the bombing of Dresden genocide? Were the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki genocide? You are an obvious anti-semite. Actions speak louder than words. Genocide by Christianity ended relatively recently. Any genocide by Judaism was more than two thousand years ago and you bring it up now. Shame !!!!!
More nonsense. Christianity has not killed millions, or even one person. However, COUNTERFEIT christianity has killed millions and millions (50,000,000 for the papal church alone).
One man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter, eh?
I have no bone to pick with the Irish.
Empires don’t become empires by playing fair, generally speaking. Savagery prevails and then gets dressed up for the awards ceremony.
At the same time, we all have our opinions as the saying goes. But a person has to decide what’s right and what’s wrong and there are some metrics that are generally accepted.
I don’t care if Bill likes Israel or he likes terrorists, Eamon de Valera or Winston Churchill, take your pick. It won’t change the outcome a bit.
Hamas, who in the opinion of most civilized people, are a bunch of murderous shits, will be wiped off the board. Yes, somebody will surely profit. Don’t care. Arabs will scream. Don’t care. Antisemites will be the trash that they are. Don’t care.
Wipe Hamas out. Should have been done a long time ago.
As Bibi specifically said it was in Isn'treal's best interests to aid and abet Hamas, (so as to sideline the PLO two state solution) ... Isn't he a Khazarian zionist, anti-semite too ??
is that your best response?? Solidifying the stereotypical traits; hubris, arrogance and chutzpah, along with ... 'projection', name calling, and derogatory statements about mothers.. I'm sure your mommy is proud of your shilling for Isn'treal too.
There is one difference between the Irish and the Palestinians. The later have no claim to the land of Israel.
A short primer on the facts; The Promised Land was called the Province of Judea while under Roman occupation in the first century CE. General Hadrian was not a fan of the Jews it was his charge to wipe Jews off the planet. His plan included luring the Jews back with the promise of rebuilding their temple, many fell of the ploy. When they learned the construction was to be a temple honoring Hadrian as a god while converting Jerusalem to a Roman retreat, the Jews staged an unsuccessful revolt. Thousands were executed the rest sold into slavery. Normal ancient stuff.
Now for the rest of the story; the Jewish historian Josephus had previously written 'The History of the Jews' and done so in Latin. Hadrian salted the land, and renamed Judea for the ancient enemy of the Jews or Philistia. Fast forward to the League of Nations mandate to UK linking the Jews to Palestine and part of Jordan. The Philistines as a people had been wiped out long before, the only knowledge such a people existed is found only in the pages of the Towrah. The Philistines as a people originally came to the area today called Gaza, and did so from Crete. To sum up there are no Philistines on the planet, so no Palestinians. The idea of a claim to the land from such a people was cooked up by Anwar Sadat. He wisely figured if such a people could be created out of thin air they'd be able to claim an interest in the land.
These people are run of the mill Jordanian Arabs. Moreover, these same Arabs gave up their citizenship when they fled Israel during the war. Israel won the war and mistakenly invited these back while restoring the Arabs to their previous status.
Israel is its own worst enemy, first by inviting the Arabs back, and then while knowing better allowing the world to believe the Arabs had a claim as Palestinians.
Contrary to what is taught in our universities, most of the land in Israel was bought off the Arabs by wealthy Jews in the 1800's these men were called Zionists attempting to establish a homeland for the Jews of the world. The land purchased was worthless desert, the paradise it has become is solely the result of the efforts of the Jews.
Regardless of what you might believe, Prophecy reveals the last generation will commence when Israel is reestablished in the Land. The end will begin so to speak according to Isaiah when Israel is thinned at the waist Gaza and the West Bank given away would do just that, and Damascus becomes inhabitable, a twisted heap of ruins. Just a note, Damascus is the longest continuously occupied city in history.
There is more, even yet, "to the story." It was Khazarians, who now genocide Palestinians, that financed Cromwell's 1649-1653+ genocide of Ireland. Correspondence between Cromwell and Ebeneezer Pratt of the Mullheim Synagogue includes the quid pro quo - the right of the Khazarians to return to England - which was achieved.
Also; the 1845-1850 "potato famine" was successful propaganda. It concealed a vast crime that saw the deployment into Ireland of more than half (67 regiments) of Britain's 126-regiment empire army. Cecil Woodham-Smith, (CWS) in her 1962 "The Great Hunger" named thirteen British regiments who had removed Ireland's abundant food crops in those years. "Ireland's" academics smeared her for the rest of her life. A few decades ago, to learn something about my Laois-born grandfather (1839-1923, a British soldier 1857-1881 in Aus., NZ, and India), I visited Britain's then-Public Record Office, in Kew. There, I promptly learned that his 40th of Foot "the Duke of Somerset's Own," had, when he was a small boy, removed the food from south Co. Galway to the port for export. Shocked, despite having read CWS's work, I researched further and put my findings into a pamphlet (The Mass Graves of Ireland). The pamphlet; despite its vast distribution, failed to silence the "famine" writers, so a few years ago I published "Ireland 1845-1850: the Perfect Holocaust, and Who Kept it 'Perfect'." It's on Amazon, etc. and is available gratis as an eBook at irishholocaust.org. The "Irish" gov't's State-owned Radio Telefis Eireann's Radio One conducted a smear "interview" of me; but my book's 4th Ireland edition sold out within weeks.
"Ireland's" gov't is entirely silent on the Gaza genocide excepting three courageous politicians who DO represent the people; Richard Deputy Boyd-Barrett, and MEPs Clare Daly and Mick Wallace. (BTW: "Holocaust" was the 1800s label used by Michael Davitt, James Fitzgerald and others. Also; starting on May 4, 1846 and continuing until November 19, 1855 conditions in Ireland were reported as "Holocaust" in the pages of The Cork (now Irish) Examiner newspaper.)
My grandfather Kieran Fogarty's parents and siblings had been evicted from their Ballykealy, Durrow farm tenancy in 1836 by English Lord Ashbrook (Henry Flowers). The tenancy was part of that Lord's 19,515- acre estate granted by Oliver Cromwell after being robbed from the local Irish. Estate Rules at the time forbade anyone to shelter an evicted family on penalty of summary evicted. Kieran was born in the emergency shelter his parents were allowed to build beside the Lord's gallows uphill of the Lord's castle gates. It is my understanding that Kieran and siblings survived the 1845-1850 Holocaust. In 1857 Kieran, to keep his sisters alive, went to Abbeyleix where he "took the Queen's shilling" (joined the British army). Later, his sister (my Grandaunt) Sara "Sally" collapsed and died between home and the Durrow, Co. Laois Post Office where Kieran's army pay would arrive.
Upon mustering out in 1881 with a pension of 3pounds 7shillings and 6 pence per quarter year, Kieran married a woman with a small tenancy and had nine children. My father, the last, was born in 1904 when his father was 65. In 1927, after Kieran died, Dad came to Chicago, met my Co. Galway mother and had a family. His two older brothers had been in WW!. One was killed in France crossing the Hindenberg Line, on Aug. 25, 1918. Thanks, Starboard Edge, for your interest.
Frankly, it getting embarrassing for me to correspond with manic antisemitic lunatics like yourself on this site. Your ignorance is galactic in scope. I hope that Bill (if he believes his posts aren’t antisemitic) will at least reflect on the quality of persons and responses attracted to his missives and wonder why they would be supported by persons like yourself. For anyone who would really like a look at the topic, please go to YouTube and search the title “Algeria Where Are Your Jews”.
As it relates to the ruling class manipulating its subjects I fully agree. As it relates to the English invading Ireland and the past 850 years of that history, it is what it is. There are a few more years of history in the Middle East and no matter what you say or think, just as man can not change climate, you will not change what happens in the Middle East. So let us get back to attempting to save the USA. A country led by elites, who feel as if they are the chosen to fix all but their own and fail at everything they touch. Let us stop letting them hide behind wars in other lands and focus on the war we have here at home.
Thank you Rich 🙏 finally a voice of reason!
Percisely ! Hit the nail on the head.
Maybe there's some kind of rat deterrence that can be used to rid ourselves of these pests.
Copper jacketed, hollow point Pb ... Or, repeated bio-'jabs' !!
Short Ropes + Lamp Posts...
Rich: Well stated!
When Bill devolved into his recent antisemitic rants of late, I wondered to myself if it was possible that one of the sources of his hatred came from his Irish heritage and a resultant confusion of the struggles between the English and Irish with the present Israelis and Palestinians. I didn’t opine at that point because I didn’t know enough about Bill besides his Irish last name. I wonder no more. Bill is seriously confusing the two.
The list of differences between the Irish and the Palestinians is VAST. Most importantly, the Irish were not backed up and funded by 1.8 billion English haters to advance their invariant charter to wipe all of England and the English people from the face of the earth.
Bill, you are far more antisemitic than you believe. You are also confused and confusing based on your personal issues, history and problems. I expected better from you.
Sadly, today qualifies for another donation to the IDF. If you’d like to help, please go to FIDF.org
Dr B -- Your accusation that Bonner hates Jews is getting tiresome.
His assessments of events are not indicative of religious hate. They are poignant observations of man's capacity for virulence.
Consider our history. Atrocities abound. Some were attributable to religious hatred; others were racial hatred; the rest were hate unleashed.
More: I have never understood why people hate Jews or Blacks or Catholics or the Irish for that matter. Totally baffling were German soldiers who worshiped Jesus -- a Jew -- murdering Jews during WW II.
All I can conclude, notwithstanding our many religions all which teach tolerance and peace, we are a species of born killers
Not that baffling. His fellow jews murdered Him. The present day jews still don't recognize their Messiah. So their hatred of jews is logical, but that doesn't make it right. There were also other reasons for the German hatred of the jews, but that's another story, which you can find on the interwebs, but you'll have to dig deep.
You make my point about our species being imbued with a capacity to hate without restraint and to murder without limit.
Previously dominating the news were daily details about two Slavic tribes -- Russians and Ukrainians -- slaughtering each other
Now, we have Jews and Arabs slaughtering each other.
Not sure what fatal feud will be next but there will be one that will be especially vicious, maybe more than one. It's our nature to kill each other for the littlest of provocations.
Selfish people are self destructive, Jimm, both to others and themselves. And, what we do to others we are really doing to ourselves. Haven't you read Discourse On Agape? None of this should surprise us.
That’s not actually historically accurate, but I’m sure that my pointing this out won’t dent the aluminum foil on your hat.
Hi Tanto -
Sorry, which comment are you referring to please?
Jesus wasn't murdered by Jews. The Vatican said so in the Second Vatican Council in the 1960's and subsequent Popes have said so as well. Furthermore a number of distinguished historians of Jesus have said so as well. It's called libel.
The Romans crucified a lot of people.
https://www.npr.org/2011/03/04/134264425/Pope-Jews-Are-Not-Responsible-For-Killing-Jesus
And, Paul didn’t have a letter from the high priest giving permission to kill followers of Jesus. And Paul himself, in his travels, was denounced and beaten by Jews. And probably, many Christians were denounced by Jews to Roman authorities.
When Germany was prostrate, from inflation and financial collapse, because Jews kept hard money, provident behavior we participate in, they improvidently bought people’s lives on the cheap.
I apologize, I didn't know that. I know that a church that murdered millions and millions of Christians, and has a large number of pedophile priests (and covered it up for who-knows-how-long), will certainly tell the truth about who murdered Jesus.
(((they))) have the rep for murdering most of the Torah faithful prophets too !! ... Hypocrit oath takers, are very familiar with practicing the genocide concept also.
Sure, we are all born killers capable of hatred. That truism aside, it’s face valid to me (and I believe many others) that Bill has directed and displaced a big slice of his own hatred’s into antisemitism which he feels compelled to present in his newsletter. I find that particularly gross, unseemly and unwelcome. If you can’t see it, little would be advanced by my listing all the examples and demonstrating their historic and present role as propaganda points for anti-semites throughout recorded history. Anti-semitism is a bit like pornography - you know it when you see it. When you share it, you will never see it.
Dr B -- When you next see a Bonner remark that reveals his hatred of Jews, point it out. Clearly, you have found this hate expressed more than once.
Although I feel my bias antenna is good and although I suspect you may be extrapolating implied criticism for actual malice, I'll keep an open mind.
Please note that my open mind does not mean I endorse Hamas' murders of innocents. Nor do I endorse Israel's murders of Palestinians.
FYI: The last time I was in Israel was during the Yom Kippur War. Probably before your time
I fully endorse the Israelis killing (or murdering, whichever you prefer) all of Hamas by the most expedient, violent methods available to them. The loss of life of so called "innocents" in the process is somewhat regrettable but since the Palestinian Charter says the purpose of so called "Palestine" is the eradication of the Jews and the Palestinians have had 70 odd years to make peace with the Israelis and yet they haven't done it I'm not overly concerned with the loss of life in Gaza. Every Hamas fighter that gets killed is wonderful news and any so called "innocents" who lose their life is just tough darts.
Sometimes picking sides and rooting for the home team is the right thing to do. Next up, Israel v Hezbollah so Bill, please don't use that one to make another analogy to make a larger point.
If your remark is to Bill, then I hope he pays it no heed
If your remark is to me, then it serves to substantiate my contention that we are a species of born killers
If you think your opinion matters to me you are sadly mistaken but I will say your reply speaks volumes about who and what you are and that is even less compelling.
Jim. If you say anything about Israel, other than extremely high praise, you are antisemitic. The same as if if I did not vote for Obama, I am a racist.
WFE: You start out great with your comment...then you do a 180 and make a very stupid remark.."if I did not vote for Obama, I am a racist"...dumb, dumb and dumber. It makes no sense. Maybe you should reevaluate your medication.
I have no idea why people hate blacks, but I know why Christians and Muslims hate Jews. Both religions have a problem besides both being utterly false. The problem is Towrah, Prophets, and the Psalms. These books teach an opposite message than both religions, and let it be noted to Rabbinical Judaism as well. The Jews with their Towrah knowledge were seen as a threat to the ruling religious elite of Rome and Europe.
Muslims hating Jews is somewhat the same idea, Surah 5:44 Indeed, We sent down the Torah, in which was guidance and light. The prophets who submitted [to Allāh] judged by it for the Jews, as did the rabbis and scholars by that with which they were entrusted of the Scripture of Allāh, and they were witnesses thereto. So do not fear the people but fear Me, and do not exchange My verses for a small price [i.e., worldly gain]. And whoever does not judge by what Allāh has revealed - then it is those who are the disbelievers.
Distilled into English: Muhammad purchased Talmud verses from the rabbis to flesh out his Quran. Nothing works better for a religion than associating with the God of Abraham. The problem exists in these Rabbis knew Muhammad twisted the verses they sold him, and there's no better way to cancel a debt than murdering the creditors.
The Roman Church as a similar problem, as did the author of Christianity Paul of Tarsus. Yahowah was very clear there is one Towrah for both the Native born and the foreigner. No need for a new covenant or new way into the family of God.
Exodus 12:49 This instruction applies to everyone, whether a native-born Israelite or a foreigner living among you.” The Jews were very familiar with this verse, a good reason to drive them underground.
Dennis T -- Your edification is as elucidating as it is provocative. The latter sensation because it makes clear that all religions are made-made.
Fortunately, all the many religions -- now and in the past -- have at their core the same sentiment; that is, "Do Unto Others What You Would Have Them Do unto You."
Hopefully, the ones certain to be created in the future by persuasive men and women will perpetuate this sensible and perpetually apt belief
(For some reason, after I finished the last sentence above, I had a flash back. It took me to the moment many years ago when I visited a museum in Instanbul. It was somewhere near the Hagia Sofia, aka the Blue Mosque which was once Christendom's second largest cathedral
The particular museum case that caught my attention explained its contents were plundered by the Ottoman Turks in the 14th century from a museum in Damascus. And there, at eye level height, was Mohammad's sword, the very instrument he used to savagely proselytize his new religion).
The ancient world was a series of thefts, Persian was robbed by the Greeks, the Greeks by Rome. The Byzantines by the Ottoman Muslim Turks, the Ottoman's by Europe, Europe by America. With lots of mayhem and murder along the way, but all in the name of one god or another.
What is lost on the adherents of all religions is the why of religion. Simply put there's no better means to install and support a cast system. The top is always the king, or landowner, followed by the generals, and religious clerics, with the bottom rung of slaves.
The Pope had an army and clerics under him, followed by serfs.
Muslims have their elites the very rich, next the Imams, and mujahideen, all others are slaves.
The God of Abraham instituted no religion, the Covenant is a family. Choosing religion, politics, or the military, puts one outside of the family.
As noted on the first tablet given to Moesh those who show love by listening and living by relying on God are counted in the thousands or one in a million mathematically. Those who show hate corrupt their children via religion even to the third and forth generation, after that time the children's corruption is self sustaining as can be witnessed in all religions. We do what our parents have done for generations, human nature is in taking the easy road, the popular path. This explains how the Arabs were not at all bothered with torturing the children of the Jews while the parents watched and then slit their throats, or burned them alive. It was all done for Allah who is greater, larger, better than every other god.
Me thinks you’re onto something. Irish hatred for the British runs pretty deep. And Not without good reason.
It was the British, once they took over the portions of the Levant, that controlled Mandate Palestine from the early 1920’s till 1948. It was the British who followed through on the Balfour Declaration circa 1915, a prescient document in light of the atrocities of the Third Reich. Perhaps it was a fit of conscience after their attempted genocide of the Irish that moved them to help found the state of Israel.
I don’t know. Just a thought.
The British PM at the time, played fast and loose with the break up of the Ottoman empire. The Arabs were promised the same lands as the French, the Balfour declaration was created to induce the zionists to induce American into WW1 causing the defeat of Germany and Russia. However the the Bolsheviks taking over Russian threw a monkey wrench into the works by publishing the secret dealings of England, the Arabs were not too happy with the same property being promised the French. Moreover the Jews were not to happy finding out the British had promised the Arabs that a declaration had no weight in comparison to a treaty.. The British went on to screw the Zionists out of their homeland. Not to worry the next time the British need the help of the Jews to induce America into WW2 they got their, homeland. Furthermore, the Jewish inventor of artificial silk (Rayon) disclosed the process to the British as a trade for the Jewish homeland. Technically, all the modern problems in the Middle East were caused by the British screwing the Arabs out of what they were promised, Israel was just the straw the broke the camels back. It's not at all about the land, Israel is a nothing compared to the millions of square miles controlled by the Arabs. What the zionists bought from the Arabs was worthless desert. Kind of like buying an old broken down homestead on the southern cost of Ireland. It has no real worth or value until a lot of effort and money is applied, then someone might have some interest.
No thought about it, You are right on . and they felt guilty about the holocaust PHN
I can only add that it’s my understanding that Gaza was considered part of Egypt until 1967. I expect their control started after the end of hostilities in 1948 which as noted above began b/c the Palestinians and more importantly their Arab neighbors could not countenance the idea of a Jewish state in their neighborhood.
Right on Mr Scott .. Please tell us more about the illegal giveaway of Palestinian land by the Brits and the USofA .
It's very difficult to apply the word illegal to international events, even when "international law" is involved it is a very difficult and complex subject.
I have a feeling you are more informed on the technicalities of the UN regarding Israeli statehood. Tip O'Neal once said that politics ain't beanbag. International politics is worse.
Awh , but the use of a better word .
Pffffft...
What is distinctive about Palestinians?
My ancestors were potato-famine Irish from County Antrim. I can't tell an Irish Catholic from a Protestant.
In fact I once met a mother and daughter in clinic who were behaving like the television caricature of a Jewish mother and daughter. When I enquired about their origin I was told "Palestinian." Oops, but I hadn't let on my initial impression.
I can tell Somalis from Ethiopians- geographic neighbours but quite distinctive. I am not sure I could pick out an Eritrean.
You report on the situation in the nearby Arab states. I have long wondered who benefits from maintaining the Palestinian segregation.
They accepted the Palestinian refugees for humanitarian reasons. I don't think they thought they would stay as long as they have.
Very good ,rjt . I, wonder the same thing. Hope you get an answer . PHN
The price of the (olive) oil that my wife likes (organic, first cold-pressed) is up from C$9.99/l to C$18.99/l from 2021 to now, so there is some hope for at least increased profitability.
Hmmmm - great info to have. Now the million $$ question:
Why does NO COUNTRY want these people? Are all the Arab "brothers" wrong, or do they 𝙠𝙣𝙤𝙬 a Reality about the people of "palestine" that our media, government, Bill Bonner and leftists refuse to acknowledge??
See my response above.
Gen. 10:4 “What Have You Done? -Said the Lord. Listen! The Blood of Your Brother Calls Out From the Ground;” in Irish, is what my wife and I have carved into all of the Holocaust mass grave monuments we have installed in Ireland. We installed them over Holocaust mass graves at the requests of locals too afraid of their government to do so themselves. The “Irish” government is extremely hostile to any recognition of those mass graves, especially to any references to the sixty-seven named British regiments who stripped the food crops from their Irish producers and exported it; starving millions to death.
Dr B, I fail to find any clue as to why you should conclude BB to be an antisemite. Anti Zionist maybe.
Hi Andre -
Yes - that is a very important distinction during these times...
I took a subscription for financial commentary and a non prejudiced world view from Mr. Bonnor and associates. I enjoy his economic theories and opinions of what is wrong with the USA and possible solutions. I agree with you on the Midfle East. Either he doesn’t like Jews or has no idea what he is talking about. I will not renew my subscription.
I don't think the Irish hate Jews, I believe a few years back the mayor of Dublin was a Jew.
One thing about the Irish no matter who you are if from America they love you.
Other than the Jews no one has suffered more than the Irish. England came very close to eradicating the Irish.
A few years back I learned my grandfather one my father's side was kin to Sean Treacy one of the leaders of the Third Tipperary Brigade of the IRA during the Irish War of Independence. My grandfather was brought over to America by Edward Stotesbury to act as his carriage driver and later his chauffeur at his estate in Wyndmoor, PA.
Who is devolving?
LOL!
Dr B, imo Bill is not antisemitic. He aspires to not be “anti” anything. He is a philosophical libertarian and as such dreams of a world in which moral judgments have been outlawed. It takes mental effort to discern between right and wrong, good and evil. Best to just close one’s eyes, cover one’s ears and anesthetize one’s mind so that no effort need be made. Notice, however, that it is impossible to not take sides between good and evil. When one refuses to identify the moral difference between initiatory force and self-defense one raises murder to the level of virtue.
There are a lot of anti-Semitic libertarians. Lew Rockwell and Ron Paul come immediately come to mind. Anti-Semitism exists in all ideologies. That it is as prevalent on the “left” as it apparently is comes as a surprise to many of the left.
I think he’s more Objectivist than Libertarian.
If you think that you don’t know what Objectivism or libertarianism is. The Ayn Rand Institute is unequivocally on the side of Israel in this conflict.
Heck, guess not. Whatever happened to Objectivists not getting involved in politics by not voting! Shows you how long I’ve paid attention! Lol! Guess every thing has its cycle. Next you’ll be telling me the Libertarian’s support global involvement!
The Palestinians have been offered peace. There is no correlation to the Irish situation. It was not an army that attacked the Israeli civilians it was a terrorist organization that has vowed to kill all Israelis. Does that include the two million moslems in Israel?
Years ago the Prime Minister of Israel even offered the city of Jerusalem to the Palestinians. A huge mistake. The Palestinians refused. Palestinians do not want peace. They fully believe, as does Iran, that Israel should not exist. Period. They chant, "death to Israel, death to America!". To them we are big satan and Israel is little satan. For this administration to give any money to Gaza/Hamas is a mistake. But the truth is, they have already given multiple billions, starting with B.O., to J.B., through Iran. They are funding our own destruction.
From the beginning of time until today there have been wars. Wishing they wouldn't happen is folly. There is a spirit of darkness, and a spirit of light and never shall the two agree. My heart is fading in its attachment to life on earth. This place is just the decision field of where we go afterward. My purpose now is to pray and hope that my children, along with as many people as possible, make the right choice.
The main terrorists in Palestine were the Stern Gang and Irgun. They were not Palestinian; but were Khazarian. In 1948 they attacked and murdered much of the populations of some 480 Palestinian towns and villages. The survivors and their progeny remain in refugee camps awaiting restoration to their homes and property. The same terrorists blew up the King David Hotel which housed Britain's local military HQ, murdering all within.
Total BS.
You KNOW so, or you THINK so?
Just curious...
Don't you have a search engine?
https://search.brave.com/search?q=israeli+terrorists+blew+up+king+david+hotel&source=web
Like I said some time back, the state of Israel was born in blood.
Many durable lies, the best lies, have a grain of truth in them. Read “1948” by Benny Morris, the history of the formation of Israel. You can see all of it. The good, the bad, and the ugly. Parse the information and make up your own mind.
Do you not wonder about the fanatical devotion of some people to assembling intricate arguments invoking all kinds of nonsense to rationalize hatred of a people they don’t even know? What kind of emotional health does that person have? You might also consider how many Jewish terrorists you are aware of in your lifetime versus Islamist terrorists. How many times have Jews shot up a school
Or a shopping mall or a restaurant, hijacked a plane, or taken hostages, or had suicide bombings performed by 16 year olds? Look around the world and let me know. The Islamist Muslims blow everybody up - Muslims, Jews, Christians, Hindus, Animists, Atheists, usually civilians. The Palestinians pay the families of murderers and stipend. Pretty nifty. And Uncle Sam subsidizes that stuff. You can figure it out.
It’s not hard to understand right from wrong even while the bombs are dropping.
"By the way of deception,we will make war" ... IDF/Mossad's meme.
Right, that’s the “meme”. You’ve nailed it. Genius.
Thanks for the info Mr. Fogarty - I am going to further educate myself.
Sounds like a charming bunch. How soon until our treasonous "government" begins openly accepting "refugees" from this area and others just like it?
Not long I'd wager - especially if they are allowed to steal the Presidency AGAIN in '24...
Mans' inhumanity to man knows no bounds and has no victors.
Nice try, Bill. Since you can't make the same case for the Palestinians, you have to substitute the Irish. But you are so biased, you won't delve into the facts of the situation, or you just skip over the facts and history that don't support your narrative. As I've said before, why you go on and on about this in what is supposed to be a financial newsletter is very puzzling. But, by contrast, it does allow me to appreciate the columns by Dan, Joel, and Tom that much more since they are more informative, interesting, and enjoyable in terms of the reason I signed up for this service.
Ditto X 10
This land was given to Abraham more than 2000 years ago by God. Palestine was never a country.
I really don't think that God gives land to anyone. The early Hebrew writers wanted to believe that they had a God-given right to the land.
God did give the land, and the whole earth, to Abraham, and his descendants. His descendants are all that have the faith of Abraham. That doesn't include the vast majority of the current inhabitants in the state of Israel. Haven't you read my little booklet, The Two Covenants? I summarize what God gave Abraham in the booklet; check it out at https://discourseonagape.org/booklets/
According to DNA studies relatively conducted by Hebrew Univ. and Johns Hopkins Univ. the current genocidists of Palestine, the Ashkenazi Jews some 98% of whom have zero percent Abrahamic ancestry, denounce anti-Semitism, while Palestinians, robbed of their ancestral lands and homes, are of some 98% Abrahamic origins.
Total crap
You KNOW so, or you THINK so?
Starboard - this is the party line from the Soviet Union. The whole genetic disassociation myth was started by the Soviets, in addition to all the ""Khazarian"dreck, which is like Snow White and the 7 Nazis, a fairy tale. Multiple studies, easily searched online from serious scientists show that Ashkenazi Jews have over 50% DNA from the Levant. In other words, more than a lot of Palestinian Arabs.
Furthermore, in my case, my brother had the genetic thing done a few years back. Before I turned gray, I was a blonde haired, green eyed kid with a slavic name. Plug my DNA into the sorter and it turns out that my family was in the Iberian Penninsula ( Sephardim) and before that in Southwest Asia, aka Israel.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_studies_on_Jews
Start there. SO when somebody boldly lies to your face, take with a grain of salt every other thing that comes out of their mouth or off their keyboard.
Many religions have been barbaric. The inquisition did not end until 1850. Unfortunately parts of the moslem religion are still barbaric. Remember, Bonner, one of their goals is to murder you.
The Babylonian Pharisee's Talmud, in conjunction with the Kabbala, and Zohar are surely barbaric to all God fearing, discerning souls.
Is there anything in the Quran like the Talmud notion that declares all gentiles are "goyim" (cattle) and all gentile women, "shiksas" (prostitutes)?
I have never heard those words used like that and I never read them in the Talmud either. Besides, what is your point. Judaism has evolved into a religion that is not barbaric unlike islam
One never finds, that which they do not first seek out.
It would be nice to learn that "goyim" is not a Hebrew word. Odd, that you do not know of it. or are not willing to explain it.
🍎🍉🍇🥮= fruitcake
False also - of course. Given that your obvious goal is to state incendiary falsehoods, I won’t put energy into tracking down each of your lies for historical correction. I’ll just write you off as full of crap.
No you are just; 'shucking, jiving', and limited hang-out, juxtaposed with strawman arguments as usual.
Two years ago the msm informed the public of the dedication of Israel's leaders to their religion. Seeing that there is so much vengeance, paedophilia, and encouragement of genocide in the Old Testament, and that Christ had introduced the anti-toxiins of forgiveness and redemption. that official Israel's decades-long genocide of Palestine is probably due to the perpetrators' religion. The horrors inflicted on Gaza cannot be condoned other than, say, in Deuteronomy. Would be happy to learn that what my eyes observe of Gaza districts rendered flatter than WW2 battle scenes, is all anti-Jewish propaganda. If only. Man's Inhumanity to Man Makes Countless Thousands Mourn. We all mourn including for those murdered on Oct 7.
Deuteronomy does not condone what is being done in Gaza, and further, does not condone violence. The Bible states facts, often ugly facts, but God does not condone them.
I leave it to someone else to educate you about the Quran, but your statement about the Talmud is absolutely false. There is no word “shiksas” in the Talmud. There is a Hebrew word “sheketz” in the Talmud which refers to the daughter of an uneducated and unobservant Jew. Has nothing to do with gentile women or with prostitutes.
your attempts at a rational justification are at best; duplicitous, and futile to all discerning (critical thinking) minds, and souls
I think Elaine from Seinfeld might be responsible for most of this confusion.
Seriously...
God is always on the side of the big battaion.
I personally know lots of Jews who abhor the Israeli Government. So using Statist illogic; they're all Anti-Semites. Completely juvenile and risible :-)
DNA tests relatively recently conducted by Hebrew University and Johns Hopkins Univ. on European Jews and Palestinians, show that some 98% of European Jews have zero Semitic ancestry, while Palestinians ARE of 98% Semitic ancestry.
Many of them have been protesting the occupation for years, and even now are protesting the massacre in Gaza.
"and even now are protesting the massacre in Gaza."
Are you speaking about the "palestinians"? I'd truly LOVE to see that, it would go completely against my "conditioning", but I strive to be accurate in what I think and believe. Always ready to assimilate new FACTS or EVIDENCE.
Link please...
No. My response was to Craig Whitfield. The substack response threads are messed up and confusing.
There’s nothing wrong with criticizing Israel the state. But when you single it out for special criticism and employ a double standard which ignores the bad behavior of every other state including the Muslim world like a lot of people do, then it’s not just Israel you are criticizing. It’s Jews. Everybody has their opinion. As far as Jews who criticize Israel, that’s fine too. But if you are a Jew who thinks that this type of criticism will score you points with the cool kids, and that they will overlook your religion and you get a pass , think again. Haters gonna hate.
Wonderful example of Statist illogic. Thanks for sharing :-)
I’m the last guy anyone would call a statist. Kneejerk dumb response.
Haters are what happens when reprobate liars hide behind race, and religion ... everyone gets smeared with the same brush.
Zionism, is 'supremacism' by assuming a false identity.
Ignorant AF. Loser. Enjoy the rest of the war.
ok boomer !!
The sad part for you is we fight back now.
You were born in the wrong era.
Douchebag demagogues and their retarded followers ( that’s you NPC) have been trying
To wipe us out for thousands of years. But they all disappear and we survive. Cry more.
who is this 'we' , that you speak of ?? If it wasn't for the US of A, Inc. being a bought and paid for zionist lapdog, you'd get your asses kicked into the next century. 'Star of Remphan' is all one needs to know.
Anti-Semitism is not anti-government.
Very true. Jews in Israel vary widely in their views of their own government in any given issue.
I’d also opine, that the conflict between an ocean of Muslims and a tiny island of Jews has less to nothing to do with governments, territories, etc., and everything to do with religious intolerance. Simply put, there are no modern Islamic countries where any other religion is tolerated. There is zero tolerance. Full stop. If all Israeli Jews converted to Islam tomorrow, the murderous attacks would cease. If jews surrendered 80 percent of modern day Israel to a Muslim country do you think the charter to kill the remaining jews would change?
Typical nonsense from Dr B. There is a large jewish community in Iran. They are allowed to worship as they please, and even have a voice in their Parliament. Many of them are descendants of the jews rescued from France in WWII by Iran.
https://search.brave.com/search?q=jews+rescued+from+france+by+iran+government&source=web
The 'B', in Dr. B ... stands for 'mierda de toro' ... the usual name changing ... a long established Khazarian practice of stealing the identity of the victim for the promotion of futher chaos, and corruption. See: 'Noahide Laws'.
Dude… get help before you hurt yourself.
hahahaha ... got the zio-shill to react ... again !!
Don't forget to donate your shekels for todays posts !!
You are sadly mistaken. The Jewish population in Iran (as well as every single Muslim country) has been plummeting for decades. The few Jews left in Iran mostly fled (if they could get out) during the Islamic revolution. Jews who lived in Iran were segregated and and discriminated against in every facet of life.
R U paid to shill, per letter, or per post ??
Yes, but the Statists among us like to conflate the two. For example, Bill Bonner didn't say anything derogatory about Jewish people or their religion. Bill didn't praise the Hamas butchers. On the contrary, he called them out for the barbarians they are. However, Bill did criticize the Israeli Governments response; the mass punishment of all Palestinians living in Gaza. For that viewpoint, Bill was labeled an Anti-Semite by the Statists residing on our forum. Nine out of ten people you run into are Statists, but they'll never admit it. However, when you know what to look for they're very easy to find. America will never regain its past glory as long Statolatry remains our national religion.
Embarrassingly simplistic analysis:
- the Jews weren’t “invaders” as Palestine was never a country;
- the Irish didn’t subscribe to an ideology calling for death to all English people; and
- the Irish don’t want to establish a global Irish caliphate!
The christian religion has killed millions so your logic is totally misplaced. Furthermore there is no genocide in Gaza. Israel has always tried to avoid civilian deaths. That is not genocide. Was the bombing of Dresden genocide? Were the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki genocide? You are an obvious anti-semite. Actions speak louder than words. Genocide by Christianity ended relatively recently. Any genocide by Judaism was more than two thousand years ago and you bring it up now. Shame !!!!!
hahaha, 'shame' is a word the hubristic, arrogant, and chutzpahed only project onto others, lacking any self-reflection.
Yes, the exampes presented were genocide !! What do you call murdering innocent people for being in a non-military significant location ??
I'm guessing, you think it is okay, if it is your team committing the atrocities .
More nonsense. Christianity has not killed millions, or even one person. However, COUNTERFEIT christianity has killed millions and millions (50,000,000 for the papal church alone).
Most of Christianity must have been counterfeit then for almost 2,000 years.
lol
Interesting history lesson not sure what it has to do with Israel/Hamas. Any parallel requires a very simplistic view of the Palestinian situation.
One man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter, eh?
I have no bone to pick with the Irish.
Empires don’t become empires by playing fair, generally speaking. Savagery prevails and then gets dressed up for the awards ceremony.
At the same time, we all have our opinions as the saying goes. But a person has to decide what’s right and what’s wrong and there are some metrics that are generally accepted.
I don’t care if Bill likes Israel or he likes terrorists, Eamon de Valera or Winston Churchill, take your pick. It won’t change the outcome a bit.
Hamas, who in the opinion of most civilized people, are a bunch of murderous shits, will be wiped off the board. Yes, somebody will surely profit. Don’t care. Arabs will scream. Don’t care. Antisemites will be the trash that they are. Don’t care.
Wipe Hamas out. Should have been done a long time ago.
Have a nice day.
As Bibi specifically said it was in Isn'treal's best interests to aid and abet Hamas, (so as to sideline the PLO two state solution) ... Isn't he a Khazarian zionist, anti-semite too ??
You mean like your mom?
is that your best response?? Solidifying the stereotypical traits; hubris, arrogance and chutzpah, along with ... 'projection', name calling, and derogatory statements about mothers.. I'm sure your mommy is proud of your shilling for Isn'treal too.
You can go Hamasturbate somewhere else, bigot. Hope you enjoy the war.
There is one difference between the Irish and the Palestinians. The later have no claim to the land of Israel.
A short primer on the facts; The Promised Land was called the Province of Judea while under Roman occupation in the first century CE. General Hadrian was not a fan of the Jews it was his charge to wipe Jews off the planet. His plan included luring the Jews back with the promise of rebuilding their temple, many fell of the ploy. When they learned the construction was to be a temple honoring Hadrian as a god while converting Jerusalem to a Roman retreat, the Jews staged an unsuccessful revolt. Thousands were executed the rest sold into slavery. Normal ancient stuff.
Now for the rest of the story; the Jewish historian Josephus had previously written 'The History of the Jews' and done so in Latin. Hadrian salted the land, and renamed Judea for the ancient enemy of the Jews or Philistia. Fast forward to the League of Nations mandate to UK linking the Jews to Palestine and part of Jordan. The Philistines as a people had been wiped out long before, the only knowledge such a people existed is found only in the pages of the Towrah. The Philistines as a people originally came to the area today called Gaza, and did so from Crete. To sum up there are no Philistines on the planet, so no Palestinians. The idea of a claim to the land from such a people was cooked up by Anwar Sadat. He wisely figured if such a people could be created out of thin air they'd be able to claim an interest in the land.
These people are run of the mill Jordanian Arabs. Moreover, these same Arabs gave up their citizenship when they fled Israel during the war. Israel won the war and mistakenly invited these back while restoring the Arabs to their previous status.
Israel is its own worst enemy, first by inviting the Arabs back, and then while knowing better allowing the world to believe the Arabs had a claim as Palestinians.
Contrary to what is taught in our universities, most of the land in Israel was bought off the Arabs by wealthy Jews in the 1800's these men were called Zionists attempting to establish a homeland for the Jews of the world. The land purchased was worthless desert, the paradise it has become is solely the result of the efforts of the Jews.
Regardless of what you might believe, Prophecy reveals the last generation will commence when Israel is reestablished in the Land. The end will begin so to speak according to Isaiah when Israel is thinned at the waist Gaza and the West Bank given away would do just that, and Damascus becomes inhabitable, a twisted heap of ruins. Just a note, Damascus is the longest continuously occupied city in history.
THANK YOU for a string of irrefutable FACTS, Mr. Dennis...
I have some land in Florida for sale, there's a bit of water on it, but very buildable. Special price for you, my friend. Sure to go up in value.
There is more, even yet, "to the story." It was Khazarians, who now genocide Palestinians, that financed Cromwell's 1649-1653+ genocide of Ireland. Correspondence between Cromwell and Ebeneezer Pratt of the Mullheim Synagogue includes the quid pro quo - the right of the Khazarians to return to England - which was achieved.
Also; the 1845-1850 "potato famine" was successful propaganda. It concealed a vast crime that saw the deployment into Ireland of more than half (67 regiments) of Britain's 126-regiment empire army. Cecil Woodham-Smith, (CWS) in her 1962 "The Great Hunger" named thirteen British regiments who had removed Ireland's abundant food crops in those years. "Ireland's" academics smeared her for the rest of her life. A few decades ago, to learn something about my Laois-born grandfather (1839-1923, a British soldier 1857-1881 in Aus., NZ, and India), I visited Britain's then-Public Record Office, in Kew. There, I promptly learned that his 40th of Foot "the Duke of Somerset's Own," had, when he was a small boy, removed the food from south Co. Galway to the port for export. Shocked, despite having read CWS's work, I researched further and put my findings into a pamphlet (The Mass Graves of Ireland). The pamphlet; despite its vast distribution, failed to silence the "famine" writers, so a few years ago I published "Ireland 1845-1850: the Perfect Holocaust, and Who Kept it 'Perfect'." It's on Amazon, etc. and is available gratis as an eBook at irishholocaust.org. The "Irish" gov't's State-owned Radio Telefis Eireann's Radio One conducted a smear "interview" of me; but my book's 4th Ireland edition sold out within weeks.
"Ireland's" gov't is entirely silent on the Gaza genocide excepting three courageous politicians who DO represent the people; Richard Deputy Boyd-Barrett, and MEPs Clare Daly and Mick Wallace. (BTW: "Holocaust" was the 1800s label used by Michael Davitt, James Fitzgerald and others. Also; starting on May 4, 1846 and continuing until November 19, 1855 conditions in Ireland were reported as "Holocaust" in the pages of The Cork (now Irish) Examiner newspaper.)
History is indeed stranger than fiction.
Sounds like your grandfather had a heck of a life...
My grandfather Kieran Fogarty's parents and siblings had been evicted from their Ballykealy, Durrow farm tenancy in 1836 by English Lord Ashbrook (Henry Flowers). The tenancy was part of that Lord's 19,515- acre estate granted by Oliver Cromwell after being robbed from the local Irish. Estate Rules at the time forbade anyone to shelter an evicted family on penalty of summary evicted. Kieran was born in the emergency shelter his parents were allowed to build beside the Lord's gallows uphill of the Lord's castle gates. It is my understanding that Kieran and siblings survived the 1845-1850 Holocaust. In 1857 Kieran, to keep his sisters alive, went to Abbeyleix where he "took the Queen's shilling" (joined the British army). Later, his sister (my Grandaunt) Sara "Sally" collapsed and died between home and the Durrow, Co. Laois Post Office where Kieran's army pay would arrive.
Upon mustering out in 1881 with a pension of 3pounds 7shillings and 6 pence per quarter year, Kieran married a woman with a small tenancy and had nine children. My father, the last, was born in 1904 when his father was 65. In 1927, after Kieran died, Dad came to Chicago, met my Co. Galway mother and had a family. His two older brothers had been in WW!. One was killed in France crossing the Hindenberg Line, on Aug. 25, 1918. Thanks, Starboard Edge, for your interest.
Frankly, it getting embarrassing for me to correspond with manic antisemitic lunatics like yourself on this site. Your ignorance is galactic in scope. I hope that Bill (if he believes his posts aren’t antisemitic) will at least reflect on the quality of persons and responses attracted to his missives and wonder why they would be supported by persons like yourself. For anyone who would really like a look at the topic, please go to YouTube and search the title “Algeria Where Are Your Jews”.