34 Comments

"This development represents “rank creep” that does not enhance mission success but clutters the chain of command, adds bureaucratic layers to decisions, and costs taxpayers additional money from funding higher paygrades to fill positions" -- Bill Quoting the NDUP Today

We have "rank creep" at EVERY LEVEL of government and I'm not talking about the military. That goes for municipal, county and state government as well as the federal leviathan. Nowhere else can one rise to a managerial position and get paid not based on the efficiency and competence with which their subordinates perform, but rather simply because those subordinates exist (and the more of them, the better the pay for the manager). Anybody see a problem with this picture?

Expand full comment

Keeping things on track w/ Bill's article: About military --Too many chiefs and not enough indians is the recipe for -disaster. There really should be a major "Reduction in force" at the higher levels.

Expand full comment

I read Bonner Private Research because I believe it educates me on economics and the history of such. Also, I really appreciate the comments because they add to a well rounded conversation and help ground me from take off. With that said in my opinion Bill does see the “forest AND the trees.”

Fraud=inflation that’s a home run. The old duffer forgot where he left his car keys…..these illustrations make us use that ten percent of our brains just a little more.

Expand full comment

This!

“Instead, the tank is sent far away, into one foreign quagmire after another. There, it serves its real purpose well. It inevitably breaks down, and needs careful maintenance and high-tech repair…involving huge additional expense. Weighing 68 tons, it is a monster headache for road repairs”.

It’s not about the tanks. Not at all. It’s about everything that goes with the tanks. And the massive opportunity for more grift, more defense contracts, more corruption. Tanks are sitting ducks for dirt cheap drones equipped with Iranian missiles. Hmm. What happened in Iraq over the weekend?

First the CIA Director goes to Ukraine. Then he visits Israel. Hmm. It’s not about the tanks. Not at all.

It’s also not about the F16s. Not at all.

Expand full comment

I agree tanks are sitting ducks….that’s the first thing I thought when I heard the announcement!

Expand full comment

How do you know these tanks are "sitting ducks'? The tanks are equipped with a Trophy Active Protection System (APS) developed by the Israeli company Rafael to address drones and missile attacks. How well will it work in Ukraine? Don't know.

Expand full comment

I don’t either. But your info helps reinforce my point. It’s not about the tanks. Not at all.

Analogous to Covid not being about a virus.

Expand full comment

I thought they might be so equipped. Thanks for letting us know.

Expand full comment

Ditto. Bill has it exactly correct. And why I said, it’s not about the tanks.

Expand full comment

I’d prefer a little more libertarian and conservative mindset at the top militarily and financially in America.

Expand full comment

From what I see and read in the media, General Milley, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, seems to have a "woke" mindset. Where's our General Patton?

Expand full comment

Our military is equipped not to ward off invaders but to defend allies

Expand full comment

I highly recommend watching a well researched documentary on the Biden family: "Riding the Dragon". You'll learn the reason we are currently fighting a proxy war with Ukraine, it's not to help Democracy flourish but to end ours.

Expand full comment

I remember when a Hershey Bar was $.5 and twice as big; there is a systemic failure losing one trillion in disposable income in Two years.

General Minihan just said we are going to have war with China in two years,”life is better when you kill the enemy, your food tastes better, your marriage is better.” Dr. Strangeglove

Read the “Bright Shining Lie,” even the best in the military have clay feet.

The US is stripping technology from the tanks. The Dineiper River is a mile wide in places and all bridges blown.

The chat is getting as crazy as the WAPO.

Read Kennedy’s book about big pharma and decided if the US is not absurdly corrupt, contemptibly corrupt.

Expand full comment

Xavier, I read the Bright Shining Lie many years ago( (still got as a matter of fact) - and it was one of the first hints for me that not everything is as it appears. It still has a lot of relevance to today with the bullshit the media are feeding us about the war in the Ukraine IMO.

Read Kennedy too but reasonably recently, so, of course, everything was a whole lot less surprising by that time.

Yes, apparently the tanks will arrive (in around 8-12 months time it appears) with all the good bits removed, and if anyone can tell me what difference 30 odd will make to the final outcome please feel free. Assuming they can find enough guys/gals to drive them when they do arrive, as they're pretty trick to handle it seems.

ITM if someone doesn't find a handbrake soon there won't be a Ukraine for them to drive around in anyway. They're getting handed their lunch bigtime, unless your only source of information is mainstream media, in which case you'll probably disagree with me. But to put it in perspective it seems that around 150,000 Ukrainian soldiers have been killed out of a population of around 35 million - assuming all the soldiers are Ukrainian - which they aren't of course, having just listened to a fellow antipidean (ex military) describing his depressing tale of life in the Yukie armed forces If the numbers are correct though it's about the same as the US losing about 1,500,000 men - in roughly 12 months!!!

Sorry, went on a bit longer than I planned and a wee bit off course, but the bloody insanity of it all and the lies and corruption does my head in.

Expand full comment

Agree with everything. The Bright Shining Lie not only is factual but a great piece of literature, something rare, wraps truth in the reality of a man, a hero, a double edged eye opener.

Expand full comment
Jan 31, 2023·edited Jan 31, 2023

Hi Xavier -

"and decided if the US is not absurdly corrupt, contemptibly corrupt."

I would wager that most (all?) of us here wholeheartedly agree that, YES, we do live in a basically corrupt society, long gone in too many areas to count.

So - what do we do about it?

Expand full comment

The first thing is to acknowledge the problem, a great % do not. Most that read Bill do. The last 6 years have been especially ludicrous but many cheer the insanity.

Next you have to pray, turn to a higher power, grow in wisdom, perseverance and courage and do all you can in your sphere of influence.

I guess you need the great collapse so that people are desolate and needy and you weed out the crazy for the tried and true, hopefully not blowing up the world.

Maybe, it is all too far gone and there is no hope but the just end of the world.

Anyway, we can keep hoeing our own garden as well as we can and transcend the insanity.

I guess that is the solution, millions converted to the truth and using talents to create good. That was America.

Expand full comment

The authorized number of active duty generals/flag officers in the US military is fixed by law. 10 US Code 526a specifies the number allowed for each armed service branch. The total is 620 officers, with another 232 officers allowed for "joint duty assignments" (whatever that is) for a grand total of 852, "approximately 900" per Bill's message. The bottom line for me is that if we have too many generals/flag officers, which seems to be the case, Congress can reduce the number, but they haven't. Why not?

Expand full comment

1971 is too late for the beginning of this country's decline. For in the early 1930s there was a joke that new coin was being circulated that contained a picture of a US Destroyer. Expecting a ship picture-- a 10 cent piece was shown. It contained FDR's picture. His adminstration began the deficiate Federal spending that made 1971 necessary.

Expand full comment

Good question! People (experts) are already saying that running and maintaining the Abrams will be a challenge for the Ukrainians because they are so different from the T-72s they have been using. I presume the same might be said for the Leopards the Germans are providing.

The Ukrainians seem to have been quick studies with putting the HMMRS into operation. The same is still to be proven with Abrams. The logistical tail for supporting these systems will stretch back to the countries of origin.

Expand full comment

The Abrams tank performed very well against the T-72 and even the T-80 tanks used by Iraq in the Desert Storm Gulf War in the liberation of Kuwait. Their armor proved vastly superior to the anti armor rounds of the Russian tank main guns. That superiority allowed the Abrams to advance with impunity to almost point blank range blow the Russian tanks literally sky high. I think that will be repeated in Ukraine. But what the US is doing is fighting Russia to the last drop of Ukrainian blood and cleaning out our stockpiles of war machines and ammunition. Meanwhile China bides its time and keeps its powder dry until the US exhausts itself.

Putin does not care how many of his troops die in his "special military operation". Most of them come from the provinces east of the Urals and from the Caucasus. Putin does not consider these really to be Russians.

Expand full comment

Hi Jeff -

What Nation's soldiers will be manning, maintaining and repairing the 100 Abrams tanks while in Ukraine?

Assumably they will be immediately deployed into combat as soon as they arrive...

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Jan 30, 2023·edited Jan 30, 2023

"Tell 𝙍𝙪𝙨𝙨𝙞𝙖𝙣𝙨 in Donetsk, they can stay or leave but they will be Ukrainians if they stay. Their choice."

Culture, Language, History and Elections be damned because Vlad Man Bad...

Expand full comment

RE your commentary of 1/30/23 under the section Iron/Brass and the FO/GO ration of 1:1400, I heard recently that the U.S. has 600+ Generals and Admirals.

Are you kidding me? Unbelievable!

Expand full comment

YESterday I was at one of my local gun clubs, and though we have had an incredible rise in Chinese ownership in land, homes and businesses in the last decade, I have never seen such a rapid increase in weapons training of any group on such a large scale.

"Chinese hoards bursting across the 49th parallel"... Thanks to our bought and paid for whores in Washington, the barbarians are already through the gate...

Expand full comment
deletedJan 30, 2023·edited Jan 30, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

So, now you have assumed the authority of telling B. Bonner what he should and should not write in his articles!! As stated above: Bill is looking at the tree's and the forest --we cannot get that

in many other places. And it did not escape my attn that you have, in the recent past, labeled Bill a 'libertarian and an isolationist'. If he is so insufferable, may I suggest you go away.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
deletedJan 30, 2023·edited Jan 30, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

PG V, I congratulate you on being one of the biggest bullshit artists I have ever read .Good luck with your personal newsletter when you get the balls to publish it.In the meantime I'm happy with Bill,Joel and the rest of the team

Expand full comment

Biden, Putin, Xi -- world class bullshit artists!

Expand full comment

Rick S. He truly is a blowhard. All this talk of being a "warrior". Weak little man.

Expand full comment

PG is a bullshit artist, how so?

Expand full comment

Dave J. I would say blowhard not BS artist.

Expand full comment

Dave, Because his facts aren't researched as Bill's are .

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Rick, You are right on,I have my own line of bullshit,sincerely thanks for calling me out on it.Its a good lesson to be learned.

Expand full comment