Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John P Gallien's avatar

I had mentioned in another post that Bill Bonner throws the occasional bomb. In today's column, he throws another one. Quote: "The honest capitalist gets what he is after by satisfying the wants and desires of others. He is no saint. Given an opportunity, he will cheat. Which is why he is so ready to send campaign contributions to Ms. Warren...". So, is he honest or not? Or are you very cynical about human nature or do you have a religious element and think that all people are basically sinners? If you had read "Atlas Shrugged" by Ayn Rand (of if you did, if you had also understood it), you would have seen the sharp contrast between honest capitalists (like Hank Reardon, Dagny Taggart, and others) vs. those that court government favors because they can't compete (like James Taggart and his ilk). Two different beings. You're either honest or you're not. Not some of the time when it suits you. What you are saying goes against the basic definition of honesty. Are you saying that no Hank Reardon's exist in this world, only people that do the right thing because they can make money doing it and will cheat at the first opportunity? If so, you come from a dark place. I bought your book and when I finish reading the book I am now reading, I will read yours. But if this is your attitude towards human nature while apparently also being a defender of the free market (capitalism), it is no wonder the Progressive Socialist/Fascist Nihilists are winning. They are winning because they present their cause in terms of morality. It's the morality of altruism, which is the morality of self-sacrifice, where the individual is sacrificed for the so-called "common good". It is incompatible with Capitalism which rests on the morality of self-interest and individual rights....which also means that you respect the rights of others. Ayn Rand explained all this not only in Atlas Shrugged but in her subsequent non-fiction books analyzing many issues from a philosophical and moral perspective. Much of this was written in the 1960's and '70's. If we had heeded her writings, we wouldn't be in the predicament we are in today.

Expand full comment
Kevin Beck's avatar

Don't forget every bottle of wine produced!

Expand full comment
35 more comments...

No posts